Free shipping on orders over $50·30-day returns on every order

Manhattan has Carnegie Hall. Brooklyn has the podcast about Carnegie Hall.

Brooklyn wrote the Etsy listing. Manhattan bought the building.

The Argument

The Metropolitan Museum of Art sits on 82nd Street and has been collecting since 1870. The median household income in Manhattan is approximately $93,000; in Brooklyn it is approximately $63,000. The L train runs both ways, but the morning commute has a direction.

The Map

Central Park

An 843-acre public green space completed in 1876, Central Park sits entirely within Manhattan and is surrounded on all sides by some of the most expensive residential real estate on earth. It was designed before the concept of a neighborhood 'vibe' existed.

It remains, so far, un-muraledited.

Wall Street

A street measuring roughly a quarter mile in length, Wall Street is home to the New York Stock Exchange, which in 2023 had a domestic equity market capitalization of approximately 25 trillion dollars. The original wall it was named for was torn down in 1699.

The infrastructure outlasted the infrastructure.

Lincoln Center for the Performing Arts

A 16-acre campus on the Upper West Side completed in 1969, Lincoln Center contains Alice Tully Hall, the Metropolitan Opera House, and David Geffen Hall, and hosts roughly five million visitors per year. It does not have a Substack.

Acoustics, not analytics.

The Flatiron Building

Completed in 1902 at the intersection of Fifth Avenue and Broadway, the Flatiron Building is a 22-story steel-frame structure whose triangular footprint was dictated entirely by the geometry of the streets around it, with no apparent concern for Instagram framing. It was converted to residential condominiums in 2024.

The building adapted; the borough below it is still considering its options.

Manhattan Over Brooklyn t-shirt — Retro Edition

Brooklyn wrote the Etsy listing. Manhattan bought the building.

Retro Edition$29.99
Dress for the co-op board.
Manhattan Over Brooklyn t-shirt — Modern Edition

Brooklyn wrote the Etsy listing. Manhattan bought the building.

Modern Edition$29.99
Wear it above 14th Street.
Manhattan Over Brooklyn t-shirt — Classic Text

Brooklyn wrote the Etsy listing. Manhattan bought the building.

Classic Text$29.99
Wear it above 14th Street.
The Other Side

Brooklyn is the most populous borough in New York City, home to approximately 2.74 million residents, the Brooklyn Bridge's land anchor, and a neighborhood called DUMBO that stands for Down Under the Manhattan Bridge Overpass — a name that describes both a location and, on certain readings, a condition. Flatbush Avenue runs 11 miles through its center, connecting Prospect Park to the waterfront, where a significant portion of the local economy involves selling things in small batches with origin stories. The borough has produced an extraordinary number of memoirs about leaving it.

The Ritual

Descend from the North

  1. Begin at 86th Street and Fifth Avenue, in front of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, which holds a permanent collection of over two million objects and charges a suggested admission that most visitors quietly decline to pay in full.
  2. Walk south along Fifth Avenue past Rockefeller Center, a 22-acre private development completed in 1939 that contains 19 commercial buildings and has never hosted a podcast recording, to anyone's confirmed knowledge.
  3. Continue to the corner of 57th Street and Seventh Avenue, where Carnegie Hall has stood since 1891, and consider that the building's continued existence requires no content strategy.

More drops

Retro EditionModern EditionClassic Text
Manhattan Over Brooklyn T-Shirt — Manhattan has Carnegie Hall. Brooklyn has the podcast about Carnegie Hall. | Above It All Tees